Maine Legal Group Logo
Main Office
Satellite Office
Consultations by Appointment Only

Eighth Amendment and the Flaw of Legislative Deference

A man in jail holding the cells with his hands, representing how one can benefit from calling a Portland criminal defense lawyer.

In several of our recent blog posts, we’ve gone over a recent case that came out of the same federal appeals court that handles cases in Maine – United States v. Rivera-Ruperto. This case is hugely important for Mainers because it says a lot about the Eighth Amendment, which prohibits “cruel and unusual punishment,” and binds the federal courts in Maine. This case is an official statement about how hard it is to challenge extremely long prison sentences in Maine under the Eighth Amendment: It stated that 160 years in jail for providing armed security in a half-dozen drug deals was not “cruel and unusual.”

The decision in Rivera-Ruperto, however, is in large part based on a concept that has no place in any Eighth Amendment case: Legislative deference.

The Eighth Amendment and the Bill of Rights

When the Founders created the Constitution of the United States back in the 1780s, there were two groups of people. One group wanted to create a strong federal government. The other wanted to reserve lots of rights for the people, thereby creating a weak federal government. The Bill of Rights is how these two groups compromised: The rights set out in the Bill of Rights were guaranteed to never be infringed upon by the federal government. This included Congress.

Among the rights in the Bill of Rights was the Eighth Amendment.

Legislative Deference and the Eighth Amendment

In the years since, numerous cases have come up that have dealt with the Eighth Amendment. Some of them have dealt with the part about punishments that are “cruel and unusual,” and some of these have dealt with prison sentences – which are made by Congress – that seem excessively harsh.

Out of these cases, courts have come up with factors to consider when determining if a prison sentence violates the Eighth Amendment. These factors, however, are not considered on a level playing field. Instead, courts have decided to give a lot of deference to the legislature – to Congress – and what they have determined is a proper sentence.

This is the idea that has no place in a court’s decision about the Eighth Amendment, or any other Amendment enshrined in the Bill of Rights: Legislative deference. The whole point of the Bill of Rights was to prevent Congress from doing certain things. To then grant such extreme deference to that very same Congress in its sentencing decisions when it comes to the Eighth Amendment is likely the least responsible thing that a court can do.

Maine Criminal Defense Attorney William T. Bly

A criminal case is not over when the jury returns its verdict. The sentencing part of a trial is often the most important part of the whole process. Having a solid criminal defense attorney at your side for the sentencing portion of your case can make a huge difference, and can ensure that your Constitutionally guaranteed rights are protected.

If you have been charged with a crime in the state of Maine, contact the law office of criminal defense attorney William T. Bly online or at (207) 571-8146.


Contact our office to speak with
one of our team members who will set up a confidential consultation to discuss your case.


Great group of people. Managed to get me a favorable outcome from a very bad situation. I would highly recommend this firm if you have legal troubles. Top notch performance!!

Dave Allen

So thankful I chose this team to represent me. They’re the best, hands down. Nathan Hitchcock proved my innocence not once but TWICE, including a trial by jury. I have a family in law enforcement who told me “Bill Bly and his team are the best. If I would recommend anyone, it would be them.”

Brandon Albert





Ready to Get Started? Get In Touch With Us Today!

If you are facing criminal charges in Maine, the attorneys at The Maine Criminal Defense Group are here to help. Call our office to speak with one of our team members, who will discuss your case with you and set up a consultation with one of our attorneys.

Get to Know Our Group
Maine Legal Group

We are a boutique law firm, and we stand out by prioritizing our clients’ well-being. At The Maine Legal Group, our experienced team offers personalized attention in both criminal defense and divorce cases.

The Maine Criminal Defense Group

The Maine Criminal Defense Group adeptly handles all areas of criminal defense practice, including experienced and skilled legal representation for state and federal charges.

The Maine Divorce Group

The Maine Divorce Group empowers individuals skillfully navigating divorce with compassionate guidance, ensuring a brighter future through the challenges of the process.